File upload failed: invalid data.

Sunday

April 02, 2006

Yesterday’s shocker at the Senate District 62 convention, during which DFLers endorsed political newcomer Patricia Torres Ray, sent some interesting signals to local politicos that will bear watching as this political season continues. The most obvious, of course, is the history-making statement delegates made by selecting Torres Ray, a Latina immigrant, over City Council Member Scott Benson, who was thought to be a clear favorite in this race. Benson, a second-term council member who had spent the past four years making connections with legislators as the chair of city’s Intergovernmental Relations Committee, is a relatively young and savvy DFL stalwart. But yesterday he was clearly identified with an old-guard party that seemed somewhat out of favor with the delegates. After the third ballot, which left him in third place behind Torres Ray and Matt Gladue, Benson persuaded incumbent Sen. Wes Skoglund to hit the floor on his behalf, a strategy that did little to enhance his standing.

Gladue, who appears to be a rising star in the party, also fell prey to a desire on the part of the convention to move beyond the old blue-color politics that traditionally rewarded labor-backed party loyalists who played by the rules and patiently waited their turn for these open seats.

A candidate’s platform had little influence on yesterday’s decision, either. In a one-party town, there is so little divergence of opinion on the issues to distinguish the candidates from one another that delegates seemed to be more interested in passion and personality than anything else. This is not to belittle the campaign that Torres Ray waged to get the endorsement. She and her volunteers clearly outworked the other candidates. But Torres Ray had the most compelling story to tell and told it more passionately and persuasively than anyone else.

It’s too early to say whether the endorsement in 62 augurs well for a particular candidate in the much-watched 5th Congressional District race, but in our conversations with local politicos it appears that certain themes are developing: There seems to be a very real sentiment against sending another white male to Washington. And anything resembling old-guard politics-as-usual may be less attractive to the party base. (Witness longtime Sabo aide and former state party chair Mike Erlandson who is working overtime trying to convince delegates that he’s more liberal than Marty was.) There’s also a sense that anyone the party sends to Washington has to have strong citywide credentials. Then, there’s the age question. Given the fact that a DFL endorsement for Sabo’s seat is tantamount to a lifetime political appointment, there are those in the party who are less likely to back a 50-something candidate.

All this may bode well for state Rep. Keith Ellison—a young black legislator with solid urban cred. But, given the role women played in the Torres Ray victory, we wouldn’t count out either Hennepin County Commissioner Gail Dorfman or former state legislator Ember Reichgott Junge. Nor are we dismissing the only Latino in the race, attorney Jorge Saavedra, who had a very visible presence at the District 62 convention. We’re also told that City Council Member Gary Schiff, a tireless campaigner who is strong on the stump, will have something to say about this race. Erlandson, of course, is a viable contender, but he’s looking less like a frontrunner all the time.

The Benson loss may have disappointed the candidate, but it wasn’t such a bad deal for the city, said Mayor R.T. Rybak. “It’s a mixed blessing,” he said. “He would’ve been effective at the Capitol, but he's unbelievably effective at City Hall, where he’s started some tremendous things that he’ll now be able to finish. I’m happy I can keep working with Scott Benson.”

For his part, Benson was fairly upbeat. “At least I know I would’ve won my ward on the first ballot,” he said later. His political base in the 11th Ward, however, may have been a part of his problem at the convention. As one veteran pol told us yesterday, Ward 11 is not an influential part of District 62, so he probably shouldn’t have been considered as viable a candidate as he was when he entered the race. Funny how geography affects this stuff.

Speaking of electoral consequences, the Benson loss means at least a couple of his prospective successors can put away their campaign hopes for a few years. Jason Stone and Juan Linares had expressed some interest in the seat. Linares, in fact, had already printed campaign literature.

One of the best lines delivered at yesterday’s convention came from state Sen. Becky Lourey, whose gubernatorial campaign reportedly got quite a boost from district conventions in the Duluth area. Lourey, a clear crowd favorite among District 62 DFLers, said, “I’m old enough to be Tim Pawlenty’s mother and I think he needs a really long time out.”


Submitted by anonymous (not verified) on April 3, 2006 - 11:34.

Ms. Torres Ray is impressive - confident and well spoken, passionate. Perhaps too focused on a narrow range of issues right now, but she makes up for that by being clearly competent to make policy choices based on the facts, not based on party loyalties, paying back favors, etc.

(And it didn't hurt that she was one of the few whose campaign literature didn't read like it was written in a Camp Wellstone workshop. Earl Netwel gets points on that, too.)

Mr. Benson comes off as an old-time tent revival evangelist, with a demonstrated commitment to back room politics.

Submitted by Sue Grieger (not verified) on April 3, 2006 - 09:56.

Initially I thought that Scott Benson was a shoe-in, but in the run-up to Saturday's 62nd District Convention, I became convinced that Patricia Torres Ray's candidacy offered something that no other candidate could match. Her campaign brought out new delegates from the Latino community, yes, and also from professionals in the social-services community who recognized her solid accomplishments.

And then there were the younger delegates, one of whom buttonholed me a couple of weeks ago to express his opinions. To this young man, the Torres Ray candidacy offered a chance for the DFL to put their money where their mouth has been with regard to diversity. And just maybe if the campaign continues to attract the kind of folks I saw at the convention, we'll bring out enough new voters to put Tim Pawlenty out of office.

Submitted by Heidi Quezada (not verified) on April 2, 2006 - 21:19.

I am insulted by your comment that the Torres Ray campaign, "clearly outworked the other candidates," not only personally, but for all the other SD62 State Senate campaigns. As Alex Eaton's campaign manager, I am not only proud of the hard work our team put into the campaign, but I am proud of the kind of campaigns all the candidates ran in our Senate District. The campaigns worked together to arrange and put on a new delegate training for more than 50 brand new delegates, we also got together the day before the convention to make sure that any possible rules or credentials challenges were resolved so that our convention could go as quickly and as smoothly as possible. In fact, I am told that our SD62 convention, with 8 State Senate Candidates, adjourned before that of SD61! Now, I haven't been around all that long, but this kind of cooperation between opponents was like nothing I have even seen before.

That said, the Torres Ray campaign ran an outstanding campaign and they have my admiration and respect. In addition, I am pleased that in the end, our district is moving in a more progressive direction with its leadership, and that is what our campaign set out to do last August.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on April 3, 2006 - 10:33.

To the victor go the spoils. I don't think it was a slam on any of the other campaigns to say that Torres Ray campaign out worked their opponents. I for one, got many more contacts from her. She made a genuine connection. Some of the candidates made me feel like I was sitting in on a public policy analysis lecture. A couple kind of "talked down" to me. On the other hand, a friend of mine told me that Patricia stopped by last week and they had coffee. Patricia literally won votes one by one in these final weeks. It was quite a sight.

Often the most personable person wins in things like this. "Working Hard" is not just about lit and phone calls. It is also about working hard to be a nice person.

I think Craig did a fair job in covering what went down. I agree Heidi that the SD 62 convention was much more well organized than the city convention last year. That whole arrangments fiasco last year was a mess. I never did quite understand who was to blame for all that.

Submitted by Fred Markus (not verified) on April 3, 2006 - 07:13.

I admire the care that SD 62 took with their approach to their convention. In contrast, SD 61's leadership chose to put our election of officers and our proposed bylaw revisions AFTER the walking subcaucuses and this had the predictable result of destroying our quorum. Now our leadership is confronted with the choice of convening a special convention - inconveniencing 500-plus delegates - or calling our central committee into session to finish what clearly could have been routinely accomplished by using the state DFL's senate district convention agenda template and addressing these housekeeping items early in the life of the convention. Control of our processes is a good barometer of the degree of change that is now occurring in Minneapolis' political life. We can well take a lesson from the evenhandedness in SD 62 that was so very lacking in SD 61.